[Product request] For itchy, angry, stinging sensitive skin?

I overdid it with benzoyl peroxide face wash and now my skin hates me. My cheeks are tingling and itchy and have been for a few days now. Super red and bumpy especially when I wake up. I’m tempted to put Vaseline on them as it’s just so uncomfortable and tingly.

My nighttime routine is usually salicylic acid wash, Elf pure toner, Inkey list omega water cream and jojoba oil, and most nights a retinol. It had been going well. I used a benzoyl peroxide wash as I was getting a few whiteheads.

Tonight I stripped everything down and just washed with a Cerave gentle cleanser and moisturised with jojoba and Inkey omega cream. Everything else stings including my makeup. Even this doesn’t feel great and my cheeks are burning.

Any recommendations for something thick I can slather on ? Aquaphor, vanicream ? Vaseline ?