It's 2021 and YouTube still hasn't fixed the "Shuffle" feature in any of their apps, or even the website. Why doesn't this work? Shuffle plays the same songs every time. Youtube Team, it's time. Fix Shuffle.

After searching through the sub it looks like this has been a complaint for years, and they still have done literally nothing to fix it.

Anyone know how to actually get youtube to shuffle music instead of just "Shuffling" in the exact same order every time?

It's getting to the point where I'm gonna have to just download copies of all of the songs and play them in VLC or something if I want an actual working Shuffle. Pretty ridiculous. Why hasn't Google addressed this?