Pick my next game!

I can’t decide between several titles in my backlog and would like internet strangers to decide for me! I’m not considering other titles at the moment because I own these titles and want to complete them before moving on. In the last two years, most of my game time has been spent on Nintendo Switch, PS4, and PC, playing Divinity: Original Sin 2, Octopath Traveler (1&2), Triangle Strategy, Mario+Rabbids (both), Zelda (BoTW x2 and TOTK x2), Kingdoms of Amalur Re-Reckoning, and Dragon Age: Inquisition.

Please help me choose from the following titles I own, but haven’t had a chance to play yet. I focus on single player and avoid toxic multiplayer experiences.

Mass Effect: Legendary Edition (played all 3 at each release but not since LE)

Mass Effect: Andromeda (never played)

GTA V (never played)

The Witcher 3 (never played)

Elden Ring (never played, sucked horribly at Dark Souls 3 and didn’t complete it)