Games you can only truly experience once

You know the games I'm talking about: Outer Wilds, Return of the Obra Dinn, Chants of Sennaar. Games where the whole point is to go in as blind as humanly possible. Games that mainly revolve around gathering information and then using that information to make progress. Metroidbrainias as they're sometimes called.

I've been on a real kick lately and have been picking up and playing through all the games I know of. So far I've played the three games mentioned, Tunic, Leap Year and Toki Tori 2+. I've also picked up Animal Well, Fez and The Forgotten City. I know of The Witness, but I've never found that too appealing.

Are there any other games that fall into this category? I just can't get enough of them.