Please help me choose between two colour covers for the basic!

I purchased two fabric kindle cases on the Black Friday Sale. I’ll be keeping one and gifting the other to my friend for Christmas. We both have the matcha basic and use a clear case, stickers, pop socket etc, but we have both been after a flip cover for more protection out of the house.

From the photos, could anyone please give their views on how each colour looks please? I’m not good with colours or decisions!

Once my friend has opened it, I’ll let her swap if she prefers the other colour, but I need to wrap one of them up for her. Maybe I should get two the same colour?

Thanks in advance for taking the time over this ridiculous dilemma 🙄