What's your opinion on replacing broken cases with new ones?

Part of me feels wrong for replacing an original jewel case from the 90s with a newly manufactured one, but part of me doesn't care because jewel cases are such generic cases that it doesn't matter. What do you guys think about it? And I'm curious if this depreciates the value at all, or if you're even able to tell.

Part of me feels wrong for replacing an original jewel case from the 90s with a newly manufactured one, but part of me doesn't care because jewel cases are such generic cases that it doesn't matter. What do you guys think about it? And I'm curious if this depreciates the value at all, or if you're even able to tell.